Active and passive 3D sensing for forest stem geometry: Comparing MLS, consumer LiDAR, SfM and Gaussian Splatting

Resumen

Accurate characterization of tree stem geometry is essential for forest inventories, yet conventional field measurements of diameter at breast height (DBH) are limited to a single cross-section and do not capture vertical variability along the trunk. This study compares five approaches for stem characterization in a Mediterranean forest: mobile laser scanning (MLS), consumer-grade iPad-LiDAR, Structure from Motion (SfM) photogrammetry, Gaussian Splatting (GS), and manual field measurements. Data were acquired simultaneously within a 2.5 m radial plot. DBH was estimated through RANSAC-based circular fitting, and stem sections were extracted every 20 cm to assess diameter stability along the trunk. All techniques produced similar mean DBH values closely matching field measurements (23 cm), with MLS achieving the lowest RMSE (1.29 cm), followed by SfM (1.52 cm), GS (1.60 cm), and iPad-LiDAR (2.26 cm). However, marked differences were observed in vertical completeness. MLS captured the full vertical profile of the stems, reaching 14.11 m, whereas SfM and GS from iPhone, and iPad-LiDAR were limited to approximately 6 m or less. The results indicate that although low-cost image-based approaches can provide accurate DBH estimates under controlled conditions, MLS remains the most robust solution for comprehensive vertical stem characterization.